Insights

Agency Network Growth Leverage Preferred Mutual's network of independent agents to expand distribution in the Northeast, targeting underserved micro-regions and offering co branded marketing and cross sell opportunities across auto, home, and small commercial lines.

Regional Market Expansion With coverage across New York New Jersey Massachusetts and New Hampshire the company is positioned for near term growth by tailoring product bundles for homeowners and commercial clients and partnering with regional brokers and municipal accounts.

Credible Underwriter A M Best rating of A and a long standing history strengthen the value proposition for pursuing larger SMB and municipal opportunities and elevating risk management program offerings.

Data Driven Selling Existing tech stack including Tableau Google Analytics and Dynatrace can support data driven underwriting claims analytics and enhanced digital self service for agents improving targeting and conversion.

Leadership and Culture Recent leadership appointments and top workplace recognition signal a growth ready partner and open doors to mid market employers and service oriented businesses seeking reliable coverage and strong client service.

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Tech Stack

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company uses 8 technology products and services including Tableau, Microsoft 365, Employee Navigator, and more. Explore Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's tech stack below.

  • Tableau
    Business Intelligence
  • Microsoft 365
    Email
  • Employee Navigator
    Human Resource Management System
  • Language Integrated Query
    Programming Languages
  • X-XSS-Protection
    Security
  • Dynatrace
    System Analytics & Monitoring
  • Google Analytics
    Web Analytics
  • Facebook
    Widgets

Media & News

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's Email Address Formats

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company uses at least 1 format(s):
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Email FormatsExamplePercentage
First.Last@preferredmutual.comJohn.Doe@preferredmutual.com
91%
First_Last@preferredmutual.comJohn_Doe@preferredmutual.com
5%
FirstLast@preferredmutual.comJohnDoe@preferredmutual.com
2%
FirstLa@preferredmutual.comJohnDo@preferredmutual.com
2%

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's headquarters located?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's main headquarters is located at New Berlin, New York 13411 United States. The company has employees across 2 continents, including North AmericaAsia.

What is Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's phone number?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
You can contact Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's main corporate office by phone at . For more prospecting data, LeadIQ has access to up-to-date and accurate contact information within our platform. Find, capture, and sync contact data to your CRM and sales tools in one click.

What is Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's official website and social media links?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's official website is preferredmutual.com and has social profiles on LinkedIn.

What is Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's NAICS code?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's NAICS code is 524 - Insurance Carriers and Related Activities.

How many employees does Preferred Mutual Insurance Company have currently?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
As of June 2026, Preferred Mutual Insurance Company has approximately 303 employees across 2 continents, including North AmericaAsia. Key team members include Chief Executive Officer: B. S.Chief Information Officer: W. H.Vice President - Actuarial Services: B. R.. Explore Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's employee directory with LeadIQ.

What industry does Preferred Mutual Insurance Company belong to?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company operates in the Insurance industry.

What technology does Preferred Mutual Insurance Company use?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's tech stack includes TableauMicrosoft 365Employee NavigatorLanguage Integrated QueryX-XSS-ProtectionDynatraceGoogle AnalyticsFacebook.

What is Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's email format?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's email format typically follows the pattern of First.Last@preferredmutual.com. Find more Preferred Mutual Insurance Company email formats with LeadIQ.

When was Preferred Mutual Insurance Company founded?

Minus sign iconPlus sign icon
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company was founded in 1896.

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

InsuranceNew York, United States201-500 Employees

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company provides property and casualty coverage to a broad base of customers. Headquartered in New Berlin, New York, the insurer traces its history to 1896 and reaches more than 235,000 customers through a network of more than 500 independent agents. 

Its geographic footprint spans New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. The company has earned an A rating from A.M. Best for financial strength. Leadership changes of note include Sander becoming President and CEO in 2021 after serving as executive vice president of insurance operations.

Section iconCompany Overview

Headquarters
New Berlin, New York 13411 United States
Phone number
NAICS Code
524 - Insurance Carriers and Related Activities
Founded
1896
Employees
201-500

Section iconFunding & Financials

  • $1B$10B

    Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's revenue is estimated to be in the range of $1B$10B

Section iconFunding & Financials

  • $1B$10B

    Preferred Mutual Insurance Company's revenue is estimated to be in the range of $1B$10B

Ready to create more pipeline?

Get a demo and discover why thousands of SDR and Sales teams trust
LeadIQ to help them build pipeline confidently.

ยฉ LeadIQ, Inc. All rights reserved.